An argument that comes up frequently on the part of pro-lifers is that abortion is wrong since the competing rights being balanced are not equal. On one hand, they argue, is the fetus's right to life, the most fundamental of all the rights. On the other, as they conceptualize it, is the woman's 'convenience.'
This is often accompanied by trivializing comments such as:
'A baby's right to life is more important than your right to a flat stomach.'
'Nine months of being uncomfortable is a lot better than murdering a child.'
'She (a fetus) needs help for a few short months...'
'Who would be evil enough to say to that person, "I know that you will die because I'm not willing to sacrifice my body for an amount of time. I don't care"...and then witness the death... Evil....'
What is the glaring, irretrievable error here?
It's that this viewpoint is wildly inconsistent with the logic applied everywhere else in life. Nowhere else do we see a person's physical health, their endocrine system, their vascular system, their skeleton and musculature and the right to make choices about this frail matrix of skin, muscle, nerves, blood and bone as a mere 'convenience.' Nowhere else do we view making one's own medical decisions as a minor privilege. Nowhere else do we see taking away bodily autonomy as an acceptable thing to do.
Nobody would, in any other context, cite the rights of others as a reason to take away a person's bodily autonomy. Most people reading this probably have both their kidneys. You also probably have both your lungs still on you, both of every organ that occurs in pairs, all of your liver.
Does the law in your country consider it your duty to donate any of these things?
Did anyone call you a murderer for deciding that you are not, right now, going to donate a kidney, or a section of your liver, or a lung, so that someone else might live?
Did anyone build on this 'murder' accusation by arguing that a renal failure patient's life was more important than your 'convenience'? Did they also crank up the emotion-o-meter by calling you selfish for not checking in at the hospital to donate anything non-vital?
If you have a significant health condition, is this viewed only as an 'inconvenience' if it is not about to actually kill you?
No? I did not think so. I rest my case.
The 'life vs. convenience' argument can sound very compelling to someone who hasn't thought in depth about the issue, but it has no logical basis. If bodily autonomy is a right the rest of the time, it does not cease being a right once a woman is pregnant.