Thursday, November 3, 2011

But What About The Men?

Another common argument that the anti-abortion movement likes to wheel out is that to give women the right to have an abortion at will is unfair to the father because the 'child' is his too. Some actually go as far as to say that abortion on demand is not consistent with 'equal rights' since the father does not get to decide too. 

In actual fact, abortion rights are very much consistent with equal rights. Why?

Because the right to an abortion is based on bodily autonomy - and everyone has this. We all have the right not to have anything done to our bodies against our will. Men have this right, women have this right, androgynes have this right, every person has this right. To give a man the right to veto his girlfriend or wife's abortion would be giving him extra rights, not equal rights. Nobody has the right to make decisions about someone else's body and to have these decisions forced on that person against their will.

In addition, the 'rights' being balanced here are one person's health and physical integrity, possibly even their life, versus the other person's wants. I don't think I need to explain why a woman's health should be prioritized over a man's wants.

Monday, September 26, 2011

'Abortion Hurts Women' (or at least, we like to argue that it does)

Another mainstay of the anti-choicers is the argument that abortion is injurious to a woman's mental health, and therefore should be illegal. Variants of this argument include pointing to a supposed condition called 'Post Abortion Syndrome' (also Post Abortion Stress Syndrome, Post Abortion Trauma...you get the idea), or referring to lasting or permanent 'regrets' or 'guilt'. They then conclude by arguing that since abortion is so damaging, women should be mandated to remain pregnant whether they want to or not for their own good.

Firstly, the existence of 'Post Abortion Syndrome' has been disproven.* No genuine evidence has been found that abortion causes any mental trauma. Neither are the dreaded 'lifelong regrets' or 'guilt' that pro-life advocates love to talk about based in fact. Some women do report stress from abortions but these are usually women with personality types who are simply prone to stress from any source whether that is going for an abortion procedure or giving birth.**

Secondly, the fact that someone may disagree with a decision they previously made is not an argument for taking away people's rights to make informed choices about their lives. Any decision can be regretted. You might decide to go to college to study biology then wish you'd done Spanish instead. You might go out with X for years then wish you'd gotten together with Y when you'd had the chance instead. Should we make all life choices illegal, because one day someone might regret them?

Thirdly, even if it were true that abortion itself and not life situations came with the risks of poor mental health and regret or guilt, this would not be a justification for making it illegal. Even if we were to accept for argument's sake that abortion causes mental distress, so can carrying to term and adopting or keeping the baby. To focus on the 'trauma' caused by abortion and ignore the trauma of having no choice but to carry to term is basically to argue that it is okay for a woman to suffer one type of trauma, but not another. It is akin to arguing that it is okay to be mauled to death by a black dog but that we should save people from being mauled by a white one.

**http://www.guttmacher.org./pubs/journals/j.socscimed.2010.10.006.pdf

*http://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/21557713
http://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/19968372
http://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/19014789

'But You're As Bad As Hitler..'

This argument is often used to stir up emotions and make people feel guilty. In people who have not thought very extensively about the issue, it can sometimes work well simply by raising emotions. You know how it works. That cold disturbing feeling like you just got injected with poison that you feel when you watch a clip of one of Hitler's marches, or read about Nazi experiments? No one wants to be associated with that by a hair, and someone not well versed on the issue will sometimes jump to conclusions simply because of that visceral sense that 'Hitler=bad', even if the subject is in fact nothing to do with Hitler and his actions.

The argument-from-Hitler usually seen flying around as an emotion-based response used to avoid answering the points the pro-choice movement is based on. One occasion you'll often see it used is when it is pointed out that an embryo or early fetus is not a person yet due to lack of brain development needed for sensing, feeling, and thinking. Pro-life advocates like to respond to this:

'That's what Hitler said about the Jews!'

This argument turns up in a few different variant forms. Another version pro-lifers are fond of using is 'That's what white slave traders said about black slaves!' Another favored tactic is to refer to abortion practice in general as a 'holocaust'.

Why is this wrong?

Two reasons. The first is that black people and Jews and other peoples who suffered oppression or abuse throughout history were simply seeking equal rights. They were seeking the same status as human beings that everyone else had. What pro-life advocates argue for is for fetuses to have special rights - an extra right that no one else has, the right to use someone's body whether they consent or not.

The second is that the argument-from-Hitler compares two things which are simply not analogous. Pro-life advocates have taken the crime of murder or genocide and conflated it with the choice not to donate one's body to something or someone else. They have equated exercising one's right over one's physical health and integrity with killing a real person simply because they are black or Jewish. That is quite obviously fallacious. What these pro-life advocates have basically done is to take a genuine right, the right not to be murdered or assaulted, and conflated it with a non-existent right, the right to use someone else's body against their will.

This is an illogical as deciding that red and blue are exactly the same. It's also fairly demeaning to actual people (i,e. women), as it implies that using another's body is a basic entitlement as fundamental as the right to clean water, health care or protection under the law, and that denying anything or anyone this 'entitlement' to use your vascular system, endocrine system, nutrients from your blood and bones, etc. is as bad as racial murder.

Wednesday, September 7, 2011

"Life vs. Convenience"

An argument that comes up frequently on the part of pro-lifers is that abortion is wrong since the competing rights being balanced are not equal. On one hand, they argue, is the fetus's right to life, the most fundamental of all the rights. On the other, as they conceptualize it, is the woman's 'convenience.'

This is often accompanied by trivializing comments such as:

'A baby's right to life is more important than your right to a flat stomach.'

'Nine months of being uncomfortable is a lot better than murdering a child.'

'She (a fetus) needs help for a few short months...'

'Who would be evil enough to say to that person, "I know that you will die because I'm not willing to sacrifice my body for an amount of time. I don't care"...and then witness the death... Evil....'

What is the glaring, irretrievable error here? 

It's that this viewpoint is wildly inconsistent with the logic applied everywhere else in life. Nowhere else do we see a person's physical health, their endocrine system, their vascular system, their skeleton and musculature and the right to make choices about this frail matrix of skin, muscle, nerves, blood and bone as a mere 'convenience.' Nowhere else do we view making one's own medical decisions as a minor privilege. Nowhere else do we see taking away bodily autonomy as an acceptable thing to do.

Nobody would, in any other context, cite the rights of others as a reason to take away a person's bodily autonomy. Most people reading this probably have both their kidneys. You also probably have both your lungs still on you, both of every organ that occurs in pairs, all of your liver. 

Does the law in your country consider it your duty to donate any of these things?

Did anyone call you a murderer for deciding that you are not, right now, going to donate a kidney, or a section of your liver, or a lung, so that someone else might live?

Did anyone build on this 'murder' accusation by arguing that a renal failure patient's life was more important than your 'convenience'? Did they also crank up the emotion-o-meter by calling you selfish for not checking in at the hospital to donate anything non-vital? 

If you have a significant health condition, is this viewed only as an 'inconvenience' if it is not about to actually kill you?

No? I did not think so. I rest my case.

The 'life vs. convenience' argument can sound very compelling to someone who hasn't thought in depth about the issue, but it has no logical basis. If bodily autonomy is a right the rest of the time, it does not cease being a right once a woman is pregnant.

Taking Responsibility, Redux

Taken from my other blog since it doesn't really need rewriting...

We hear this argument a lot on the subject of abortion and body autonomy: that since in most cases the woman chose to have sex, she should 'take responsibility' and carry to term.

This is wild illogic and it outright scares me how much credibility this argument seems to hold.

For one reason, willingly having a child when you neither want one nor are in an appropriate situation to have one is clearly anything but responsible. If someone can explain how it's 'responsible' for a woman who already has six children and can't afford another one to have that seventh when the rest are struggling, or how it's 'responsible' for a young adolescent girl who barely has rounded hips yet and who is more likely to have severe complications to carry to term...I'm all ears. As it is this reasoning seems less about genuine responsibility and more another branch of slut-shaming. 

Secondly, in no other context do we demand that people accept any and all consequences of their actions, decline to do anything to control the outcome of those actions, and equate this 'ballistic' decision-making style with 'taking responsibility'. An analogy would be this:

You are out on your motorbike. You are responsibly riding under the speed limit and obeying all the rules of the road, but the oncoming yob isn't so careful and knocks you into the ditch. According to the 'responsibility' argument, you chose to go out on your motorbike, so now you should 'take responsibility' and choose not to seek medical attention or even treat your injuries by yourself. 

That sounds hysterically stupid and anything but responsible, doesn't it? Yes, I thought so. And indeed, nowhere else do we take the view that once you've chosen an action you are now obliged to accept any and all consequences of that action and label this 'responsibility'. Yet we make this one exception for the subject of abortion - for some reason, many people seem to think that the usual rules of reason and common sense shouldn't apply. 

Another variant of this argument that frequently pops up is the idea that abortion is an 'easy way out', as if a woman owed it to someone or other to bear a baby and bodily autonomy were some minor luxury to be taken away like a schoolchild's computer privileges as a punishment. 

One - a solution to a problem is not equivalent to an 'easy way out'. You don't want to have a headache, so you take some codeine. You don't want to have a broken leg, so you go to the hospital to have it set. You don't want to be pregnant, so...wait for it...you have the abortion. Why are women any more obliged to accept an unwanted pregnancy than any other medical condition?

And two - even if we decided for argument's sake to agree that having an abortion is an 'easy way out' - this is not grounds for making something illegal. Weak or lazy is not the same as immoral. I have a short hairstyle because it's easier to take care of, should that be illegal on grounds of being 'easy', too?

I've seen otherwise reasonable people and even people who consider themselves pro-choice argue for restrictions on 'responsibility' or 'easy way out' grounds, and it's something we should all take note of - abortion should not be considered a logical void where the usual rules do not apply.