Monday, September 26, 2011

'Abortion Hurts Women' (or at least, we like to argue that it does)

Another mainstay of the anti-choicers is the argument that abortion is injurious to a woman's mental health, and therefore should be illegal. Variants of this argument include pointing to a supposed condition called 'Post Abortion Syndrome' (also Post Abortion Stress Syndrome, Post Abortion Trauma...you get the idea), or referring to lasting or permanent 'regrets' or 'guilt'. They then conclude by arguing that since abortion is so damaging, women should be mandated to remain pregnant whether they want to or not for their own good.

Firstly, the existence of 'Post Abortion Syndrome' has been disproven.* No genuine evidence has been found that abortion causes any mental trauma. Neither are the dreaded 'lifelong regrets' or 'guilt' that pro-life advocates love to talk about based in fact. Some women do report stress from abortions but these are usually women with personality types who are simply prone to stress from any source whether that is going for an abortion procedure or giving birth.**

Secondly, the fact that someone may disagree with a decision they previously made is not an argument for taking away people's rights to make informed choices about their lives. Any decision can be regretted. You might decide to go to college to study biology then wish you'd done Spanish instead. You might go out with X for years then wish you'd gotten together with Y when you'd had the chance instead. Should we make all life choices illegal, because one day someone might regret them?

Thirdly, even if it were true that abortion itself and not life situations came with the risks of poor mental health and regret or guilt, this would not be a justification for making it illegal. Even if we were to accept for argument's sake that abortion causes mental distress, so can carrying to term and adopting or keeping the baby. To focus on the 'trauma' caused by abortion and ignore the trauma of having no choice but to carry to term is basically to argue that it is okay for a woman to suffer one type of trauma, but not another. It is akin to arguing that it is okay to be mauled to death by a black dog but that we should save people from being mauled by a white one.

**http://www.guttmacher.org./pubs/journals/j.socscimed.2010.10.006.pdf

*http://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/21557713
http://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/19968372
http://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/19014789

No comments:

Post a Comment