Monday, September 26, 2011

'But You're As Bad As Hitler..'

This argument is often used to stir up emotions and make people feel guilty. In people who have not thought very extensively about the issue, it can sometimes work well simply by raising emotions. You know how it works. That cold disturbing feeling like you just got injected with poison that you feel when you watch a clip of one of Hitler's marches, or read about Nazi experiments? No one wants to be associated with that by a hair, and someone not well versed on the issue will sometimes jump to conclusions simply because of that visceral sense that 'Hitler=bad', even if the subject is in fact nothing to do with Hitler and his actions.

The argument-from-Hitler usually seen flying around as an emotion-based response used to avoid answering the points the pro-choice movement is based on. One occasion you'll often see it used is when it is pointed out that an embryo or early fetus is not a person yet due to lack of brain development needed for sensing, feeling, and thinking. Pro-life advocates like to respond to this:

'That's what Hitler said about the Jews!'

This argument turns up in a few different variant forms. Another version pro-lifers are fond of using is 'That's what white slave traders said about black slaves!' Another favored tactic is to refer to abortion practice in general as a 'holocaust'.

Why is this wrong?

Two reasons. The first is that black people and Jews and other peoples who suffered oppression or abuse throughout history were simply seeking equal rights. They were seeking the same status as human beings that everyone else had. What pro-life advocates argue for is for fetuses to have special rights - an extra right that no one else has, the right to use someone's body whether they consent or not.

The second is that the argument-from-Hitler compares two things which are simply not analogous. Pro-life advocates have taken the crime of murder or genocide and conflated it with the choice not to donate one's body to something or someone else. They have equated exercising one's right over one's physical health and integrity with killing a real person simply because they are black or Jewish. That is quite obviously fallacious. What these pro-life advocates have basically done is to take a genuine right, the right not to be murdered or assaulted, and conflated it with a non-existent right, the right to use someone else's body against their will.

This is an illogical as deciding that red and blue are exactly the same. It's also fairly demeaning to actual people (i,e. women), as it implies that using another's body is a basic entitlement as fundamental as the right to clean water, health care or protection under the law, and that denying anything or anyone this 'entitlement' to use your vascular system, endocrine system, nutrients from your blood and bones, etc. is as bad as racial murder.

No comments:

Post a Comment